Atlantic Forecast Vol. 1

Mapping the division’s goaler landscape

I first starting thinking about this concept when Melnyk made his infamous unparalleled success statement. As soon as the organization officially timestamped their rebuild, I started wondering what the division might look like over the next five years. After all, no matter how good of a prospect pool Ottawa creates, they still have to keep the pace with their rivals. Now, it should go without saying that there are an infinite number of moving parts involved: salary cap, trades, drafts, expansion, expiring contracts, and injuries among others.

Just like John Donne said though, no man is an island, and as promising as the future seems in Ottawa, the seven other teams in the Atlantic division have stockpiled young talent too. With this series, I would like to give you an idea of what the future of the division could look like, starting this week with backstops. Goalies seemed to me the best (because of the manageable amount of data) and worst (because of the volatility of goalie stats) place to start. I consider everything here subject to change and you may really have to relax your eyes before the picture comes into focus.

Just to explain my methodology here, I focused on prospects 25-and-under as opposed to veterans. For all goalies, I used all-situation save percentage at the midway mark of this current season. Ideally with more resources at my disposal I would rank all players across their entire leagues and across seasons instead of limiting myself to to this lone season. With that in mind, let’s start with what we know best.

Ottawa Senators

Assuming Craig Anderson (2020) and Anders Nilsson (2021) move on by the end of their current contracts, Marcus Hogberg profiles as heir to the throne in the nation’s capital. And, at age 25, Hogberg’s projected prime years line up almost exactly with Melnyk’s promised window of contention this decade. Ottawa’s depth chart looks like:

  • Marcus Hogberg: 90.1% in the NHL and 89.7% in the AHL
  • Joey Daccord: 91.4% in the AHL and 90.1% in the ECHL
  • Filip Gustavsson: 88.4% AHL
  • Kevin Mandolese: 2nd in QMJHL among qualifiers at 92%
  • Mads Sogaard: Failed to crack the top 15 among WHL goalies at 90%/

While they never received the type of hype that prospects like Gustavsson and Sogaard earned given their daft pedigree (both second-rounders), Daccord (seventh round) and Mandolese (sixth round) remain my dark horses in the Senators system to challenge Hogberg given their numbers. All of Gustavsson, Sogaard, and Mandolese have several years to put it together. In the meantime Ottawa could do much worse than a young tandem of Hogberg and Daccord.

Boston Bruins

Much to my surprise, Boston only has Tuukka Rask, age 32, under contract until the end of next season and from what I’ve seen putting this article together, they may have to consider letting their current franchise goalie walk away when the time comes. Boston also has Jaroslav Halak and Maxime Lagace on affordable professional contracts for this season for depth. In terms of the future in Boston’s crease, the Bruins have:

  • Daniel Vladar: 93.5% AHL
  • Jeremy Swayman: 93.6% NCAA
  • Kyle Keyser: 89% AHL/

With Swayman, age 21, putting up a 93.6% through 22 NCAA games and Vladar, age 22, rocking a 93.5% for Providence in the AHL, Boston looks like a much more formidable opponent in the Atlantic division over the next five years if they choose to tap into that young potential as opposed to overpaying for Tuukka Rask’s mid- to late-thirties.

Buffalo Sabres

Buffalo, in the short term, has a rather straightforward goalie situation with veterans Andrew Hammond :( and Carter Hutton coming off the books this year and next. At age 26, Linus Ullmark currently holds court for the Sabres and should continue to do so for at least the next couple seasons if he continues to provide a respectable 91% as a full-time NHLer. In terms of prospective talent in the crease, Buffalo should make Ottawa somewhat nervous. And as a Senators fan who considered Dominik Hasek the boogeyman as a child, it really pains me to inform you that Buffalo may have another Sens-killer waiting in the wings. Behold the horror:

  • Jonas Johansson: 92.4% AHL
  • Ukko-Pekka Luukkonen: 91.7% ECHL
  • Erik Portillo: Tied for 5th in USHL at 91.2%/

At age 24, Johansson is hot on the heels of Ullmark. The Belleville Senators should get familiar with Jonas in the AHL as they will likely continue squaring off against both Johansson and Ullmark in Ottawa over the next few years. Luukkonen ranks among the top goaltending prospects in all of hockey and if he keeps up his current pace of development, he could start tormenting us in Ottawa right in time to spoil our projected window of contention. At just 19 years of age, the jury remains out on Erik Portillo.

Detroit Red Wings

I don’t envy myself writing this one as Detroit currently hasten goalies in their system and not without a few duds. At age 35 and with an expiring contract, Jimmy Howard finds himself in a situation not unlike Craig Anderson’s. The Red Wings have veterans Johnathan Bernier and Calvin Pickard backing up Howard at the professional level and then we get into the seven prospects:

  • Victor Brattstrom: 7th in Allsvenskan at 91.2%
  • Joren Van Potelberghe: 11th in NLA at 91.2%
  • Filip Larsson: 84.3% AHL and 88.6% ECHL
  • Kaden Fulcher: 83.1% ECHL
  • Keith Petruzzelli: 91.5% NCAA
  • Jesper Eliasson: 19th in Allsvenskan at 89.7%
  • Carter Gylander: 1st in the AJHL at 92.6%/

Detroit’s two most intriguing prospects bookend that list with a lot of mediocrity in the middle. At age 22, Brattstrom could come over to North America in the the coming months as Detroit must offer a contract or lose his rights this summer. Petruzzelli has a respectable 91.5% in the NCAA this season while Eliasson and Gylander look promising but require several more years of seasoning. Despite lacking a clear-cut heir apparent like Marcus Hogberg, Detroit’s pipeline reminds me the most of Ottawa’s with a lot of names across several leagues as opposed to one or two high-profile prospects.

Florida Panthers

The Cats have a bit of everything going on. Bloggers have discussed Sergei Bobrovsky’s mammoth $70,000,000 contract that runs through 2026 (and coincidentally through Ottawa’s ‘years of unparalleled success’). At age 31, and quickly declining in performance, Bobrovsky may serve as the one of the NHL’s most expensive stopgaps until the young Cats come of age. A familiar fellow has backed up Bobrovsky recently and tops off Florida’s depth chart:

  • Chris Driedger: 93.5% in the NHL and 93.8% AHL
  • Philippe Desrosiers: 91.9% AHL
  • Samuel Montembeault: 88.9% in the NHL and 91.6% AHL
  • Ryan Bednar: 91% ECHL
  • Spencer Knight: 93.7% NCAA/

It turns out Ottawa may have passed on a good one in Chris Driedger. Their former third-round selection has enjoyed quite the renaissance season down south and he could step into a starting role depending how dire the Bobrovsky situation becomes. Overall, Florida’s goalie depth chart may impress me the most of any in the division. It doesn’t hurt that their youngest netminder may arguably hold the title of most-hyped goalie prospect since Carey Price. In his freshman season in the NCAA, Spencer Knight already has an exceptional 93.7 sv% at age 18(!). Everything I said about Luukkonen applies for Knight and his potential to torment the Senators for years to come while the other four prospects on this list have numbers over 90% in the minors.

Montreal Canadiens

Much like Bobrovsky, Carey Price and his mastodonic contract should determine what happens in Montreal’s crease in the coming years. With six years and $63,000,000 left on the books for the 32-year-old, Montreal with have to swallow a very bitter pill to pave the way for a younger ‘tender. The Canadiens have Keith Kinkaid under contract for the remainder of this season and Charlie Lindgren until 2021 in backup capacities at the professional level. In the pipeline, Montreal has:

  • Michael McNiven: 90.9% ECHL
  • Cayden Primeau: 93.1% NHL and 90.2% AHL
  • Frederik Nissen Dichow: Tied for 20th in Superelit at 87.8%/

With a very shallow pool to work with, we can almost guarantee that Ottawa will predominantly see a Price and Primeau tandem in the coming years as McNiven doesn’t really seem like a prospect and Nissen has several years of development ahead before Montreal knows what they have in the young Dane.

Tampa Bay Lightning

The Lightning have their starter locked up through 2028 in Andrei Vasilevskiy. Meanwhile they have Mike Condon’s dead contract on the books for the remainder of this season and  Scott Wedgewood’s somewhat alive contract for the purpose of professional depth. Curtis McElhinney will back up Vasilevskiy until the end of 2021. The Lightning’s youth movement looks like this:

  • Andrei Vasilevskiy: 91.5% NHL
  • Spencer Martin:  88.8% AHL and 91.5% ECHL
  • Kristian Oldham: N/A NCAA
  • Ty Taylor: 89.5% NCAA
  • Magnus Chrona: 91.7% NCAA
  • Hugo Alnefelt: 92.3% SHL (would qualify for top five if he had ten or more games played)/

Tampa Bay took something of an unorthodox approach signing Vasileskiy to his BIG contract in his twenties (many netminders don’t get to cash in until their thirties). Ottawa can realistically expect to face Vasilevskiy as the Lightning’s starting goalie for the foreseeable future as Tampa Bay’s two most intriguing prospects in the crease, Chrona and Alnefelt, don’t have to sign professional contracts before 2022 and 2023 respectively and Vasilevskiy has tied up the Lightning’s goaltending budget for the better part of the decade.

Toronto Maple Leafs

Much like my misconceptions about Boston, I had not reckoned that Frederik Andersen had entered his thirties and that his contract expires after next season. Given Toronto’s cap situation, I wouldn’t feel surprised to see the Leafs part ways with Andersen after 2021 and roll the dice on one of their younger, more affordable goalies. For this season at least, Toronto has veteran Michael Hutchinson in a backup role and knocking at the proverbial door they have 26-year-old Kasimir Kaskisuo. In the minors and juniors, Toronto has:

  • Ian Scott: N/A AHL
  • Joseph Woll: 89.2% AHL
  • Zach Bouthillier: 20th in QMJHL at 89.4%/

None of the numbers associated with Toronto’s young goalies inspire a tonne of confidence and that includes Kaskisuo. With Andersen’s free agency looming and a shallow talent pool at their disposal, I would consider Toronto’s situation in the crease the most tenuous of any team in the division heading into the next decade of hockey in the Atlantic.

All stats and figures courtesy of capfriendly and elite prospects.


NameAffiliationDrafted overallAgeLeagueGamesSv%ContractCap hit (in millions)
Condon, MikeLightningN/A29AHL487.6UFA 20202.400
Daccord, JoeySenators19923AHL1191.4RFA 20200.925
Desrosiers, PhilippePanthers5424AHL1791.9RFA 20200.700
Driedger, ChrisPanthers7625AHL1493.8UFA 20210.850
Gustavsson, FilipSenators5521AHL1588.4RFA 20210.762
Hammond, AndrewSabresN/A31AHL2290.2UFA 20200.700
Hogberg, MarcusSenators7825AHL1589.7RFA 20210.700
Howard, JimmyRed Wings6435AHL291.7UFA 20204.000
Hutchinson, MichaelMaple Leafs7729AHL394.2UFA 20200.700
Johansson, JonasSabres6124AHL1892.4RFA 20200.759
Kaskisuo, KasimirMaple LeafsN/A26AHL1991.1RFA 20200.675
Keyser, KyleBruinsN/A20AHL689.0RFA 20220.733
Kinkaid, KeithCanadiensN/A30AHL789.5UFA 20201.750
Lagace, MaximeBruinsN/A27AHL2291.7UFA 20200.700
Larsson, FilipRed Wings16721AHL784.3RFA 20220.837
Lindgren, CharlieCanadiensN/A26AHL1689.3UFA 20210.750
Martin, SpencerLightning6324AHL2088.8RFA 20200.700
Montembeault, SamuelPanthers7723AHL991.6RFA 20200.709
Pickard, CalvinRed Wings4927AHL2490.2UFA 20210.750
Primeau, CaydenCanadiens19920AHL1890.2RFA 20220.881
Scott, IanMaple Leafs11021AHLN/AN/ARFA 20220.806
Vladar, DanielBruins7522AHL1293.5RFA 20200.729
Wedgewood, ScottLightning8427AHL1489.1UFA 20200.700
Woll, JosephMaple Leafs6221AHL1689.2RFA 20210.800
Gylander, CarterRed Wings19118AJHL2492.6ELC 2024N/A
Brattstrom, VictorRed Wings16022Allsvenskan3291.2ELC 2020N/A
Eliasson, JesperRed Wings8419Allsvenskan1589.7ELC 2022N/A
Bouthillier, ZachMaple Leafs20920CHL3089.4ELC 2020N/A
Mandolese, KevinSenators15719CHL2392.0ELC 2020N/A
Sogaard, MadsSenators3719CHL2590.0ELC 2021N/A
Bednard, RyanPanthers20622ECHL2291.0RFA 20210.818
Daccord, JoeySenators19923ECHL1290.1RFA 20200.925
Fulcher, KadenRed WingsN/A21ECHL283.1RFA 20220.733
Keyser, KyleBruinsN/A20ECHL181.8RFA 20220.733
Larsson, FilipRed Wings16721ECHL388.6RFA 20220.837
Luukkonen, Ukko-PekkaSabres5420ECHL2091.7RFA 20200.779
Martin, SpencerLightning6324ECHL491.5RFA 20200.700
McNiven, MichaelCanadiensN/A22ECHL190.9RFA 20200.682
Vladar, DanielBruins7522ECHL190.9RFA 20200.729
Chrona, MagnusLightning15219NCAA1891.7ELC 2022N/A
Knight, SpencerPanthers1318NCAA1793.7ELC 2023N/A
Oldham, KristianLightning15322NCAAN/AN/AELC 2021N/A
Petruzzelli, KeithRed Wings8820NCAA2191.5ELC 2021N/A
Swayman, JeremyBruins11121NCAA2293.6ELC 2021N/A
Taylor, TyLightning21420NCAA689.5ELC 2022N/A
Andersen, FredMaple Leafs8730NHL3591.4UFA 20215.000
Anderson, CraigSenators7738NHL2189.7UFA 20204.750
Bernier, JonathanRed Wings1131NHL2890.4UFA 20213.000
Bobrovsky, SergeiPanthersN/A31NHL3489.6UFA 202610.000
Driedger, ChrisPanthers7625NHL793.5UFA 20210.850
Halak, JaroslavBruins27134NHL1992.3UFA 20202.750
Hogberg, MarcusSenators7825NHL990.1RFA 20210.700
Howard, JimmyRed Wings6435NHL1788.4UFA 20204.000
Hutchinson, MichaelMaple Leafs7729NHL1189.2UFA 20200.700
Hutton, CarterSabresN/A34NHL1789.2UFA 20212.750
Kaskisuo, KasimirMaple LeafsN/A26NHL184.2RFA 20200.675
Kinkaid, KeithCanadiensN/A30NHL687.5UFA 20201.750
Lindgren, CharlieCanadiensN/A26NHL290.8UFA 20210.750
McElhinney, CurtisLightning17636NHL1190.4UFA 20211.300
Montembeault, SamuelPanthers7723NHL788.9RFA 20200.709
Nilsson, AndersSenators6229NHL2090.8UFA 20212.600
Pickard, CalvinRed Wings4927NHL281.8UFA 20210.750
Price, CareyCanadiens532NHL3790.4UFA 202610.500
Primeau, CaydenCanadiens19920NHL293.1RFA 20220.881
Rask, TuukkaBruins2132NHL2792.5UFA 20217.000
Ullmark, LinusSabres16326NHL2891.0RFA 20201.325
Vasilevskiy, AndreiLightning1925NHL3391.5UFA 20289.500
Van Pottelberghe, JorenRed Wings11022NLA1791.2IndefiniteN/A
Alnefelt, HugoLightning7118SHL992.3ELC 2023N/A
Nissen Dichow, FrederikCanadiens13818Superelit1987.8ELC 2023N/A
Portillo, ErikSabres6719USHL1791.2ELC 2023N/A

Not everyone can afford to pay for sports coverage right now, and that is why we will keep as much of the site's content free for as long as we can.

But if you are able to, please consider subscribing to help keep our articles free (and get a few extra perks).

Erik Condra
  • Ability to comment and participate in our community
  • Twice monthly newsletter available only to subscribers
  • Ad-free reading
  • Our undying love and appreciation
Brady Tkachuk
  • Everything from the Erik Condra tier
  • 10% discount on all merch
  • Access to any future paywalled content
  • A personal thank-you from the Silver Seven staff
Daniel Alfredsson
  • Everything from the Brady Tkachuk tier
  • Inner peace knowing you are supporting quality, independent coverage of your favourite sports team