Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: Terry Collins, David Wright, And The Mets/Brewers Kerfuffle

Enhance your experience: The Green Line


Across the SB Nation blogging network today, you're going to see most hockey sites come up with different ways to 'enhance the experience' of hockey. Some are talking NHL hockey, some hockey in general, some... are probably going pretty far out. It's all part of a campaign SBN is doing in partnership with Samsung.

Let's be honest with each other for a second.  You know what's bullcrap?  Not knowing if a goal has been scored or not.  This is the 21st century, and yet we still have to put up with annoying video reviews where we wait through agonizing television replays as announcers debate whether or not they can see the puck.  And what's maddening is that you know the same exact conversation is going on in the so-called "war room" in Toronto.

"Uh, I don't know.  Can you see it there?"

"No.  Let's try another angle.  How about that?"

"Nah."

"What do you want to do?"

"I dunno.  Coin Flip?"

Yep... bullcrap.  Luckily, there's an easy solution: Put a quarter-inch green line in the goal.

Star-divide

You're probably thinking, "That's great, Mark, but what's a green line going to do?"

However, this wouldn't be just any green line.  It's an RF-chip embedded line.  Pair it with an RF-chip embedded puck, and you're well on your way to having a foolproof system for declaring goals.

The best part of this is that it works in conjunction with existing NHL rules.  All the league needs to do is put the line exactly the diameter of a puck behind the existing goal line.  The thought behind that distance is simple -- in order for a goal to count, it has to completely cross the goal line.  With a simple radio wave, any time the puck has broken the plane of the green line, you know beyond any shadow of a doubt that a goal has been scored.  The puck touches the green line, and the red line goes on.  No guesswork.

In Ottawa, we've already seen a disallowed goal because officials couldn't see the puck underneath bodies, and I'm willing to bet every NHL team will experience the same scenario at least once this year.  It's only a matter of time before one of those goals is one that decides a game this year, and that's an easy black eye for the NHL to avoid.

We already know that the puck can be modified thanks to Fox's broadcasts in the 90's.  But instead of trying to cartoonize the game, the league should be using technology to enhance it. 

The rules of the game state that if the puck crosses the goal line, then a goal has been scored.  It's time to start counting those goals with technology and not eyes.

Comment 8 comments  |  0 recs  | 

Do you like this story?

Comments

Display:

the point

When i talk on the phone, i always prefer a real person then a phone tree. I would accept a human mistakes more then a computer one.

by Bikini Cowboy on Nov 5, 2010 9:29 AM EDT reply actions  

What if the puck completely crosses the line, yet is not lying flat? It wouldn’t reach the RF line.

Just bustin’ balls here. Of course they could figure out a way to install a chip into a puck that withstands freezing and jarring. I’m sure Samsung could develop such a thing. BTW, I thought the point of these was to enhance my experience using a Samsung product.

by Spezzal Teams Playa on Nov 5, 2010 9:30 AM EDT reply actions  

But... but...

I mean, really, how often does a puck that’s not lying flat get obscured? I’m not suggesting we take away officials’ ability to call goals, just their ability to wave it off because they’re not sure it crossed.

Silver Seven - The Daniel Alfredsson of Ottawa Senators Blogs

by Mark Parisi on Nov 5, 2010 11:51 AM EDT up reply actions  

That is a great idea

I have one comment though, what if the computer says it is a goal, but the referee is almost certain it did not cross the line? (let’s say a computer glitch). Would you the referee have the guts to overturn the computer? Or would he be allowed to?

Sens fan in Toronto since 2000. (Thank you Martin Havlat).

by Adnan on Nov 5, 2010 1:26 PM EDT reply actions  

Also, don`t forget about the amount of cheating that can go undetected

Easily install a code of some sort and the whole thing can be thrown off. Bribing refs is much easier to catch and trace.

by superjarvo on Nov 6, 2010 1:53 AM EDT reply actions  

Spot on Mark!

You would think after the way the Stanley Cup Finals ended the NHL would try to implement a system that would enhance the way the reviews were done or at least how reviews are looked at.

Another prime example was Game 4 of the Finals when the puck appeared to cross the line on one angle, but not in another. Yet, it was ruled a goal when that wasn’t the call on the ice. It’s the overall inconsistency that drives everyone crazy.

One the same subject, how does everyone feel about Dale Tallon’s coaches challenge?

2010 STANLEY CUP CHAMPIONS
It's been a long journey but in the end it was all worth it, and I wouldn't have ever changed a thing. The feeling is so surreal, yet so real.

by hawks61 on Nov 6, 2010 10:35 AM EDT reply actions  

Let the goalies win a few!!!

This sounds like a wonderful suggestion at first glance. In a perfect world where people could be trusted, a computerized system to figure out if the puck crossed the line would work. Trouble is the measuring stick is only “cheat as long as you don’t get caught”… so someone would figure out how to program the computer to screw up the system and declare goals that were close but did not cross the line as goals.

If you let goalies wear gloves the size of the face off circle they would in order to be able to pull the puck out of the net undetected. If you let shooters use sticks that can propel the puck over 100 miles an hour, they would… oh they do allow that akready???…. Oh!!!

The point is everyone cheats and pushes the rules and the system as far as they can. With illegal sticks and everything else, the advantage is in favour of the shooters… So let the goalies win a few of these disputes, and in he end it comes out even.

by Marvellous on Nov 6, 2010 12:25 PM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

The unofficial Ottawa Senators blog

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Sb_small
Alfie: "The kids want me to continue."

Recent FanPosts

Small
BM's summer vacation
Nhl_entry_draft_portraits_8_xtv5um7c5l_small
A look at senators depth: Center Addition
Marv_facebook_small
Our style won't win us any playoff series
Karlssonpoint_small
Playoffs prediction competition: round three
Small
Sens sign D Fredrik Claesson to three-year entry-level deal.
388792_930152605465_90404761_43022916_1197799002_n_small
Ban on Brennan
Karlsson_small
2012 UFA: Ryan Suter, The Pipe Dream
Small
Should there be a limit to Loyalty?
Small
Kleinendorst leaving the Sens organization

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >


Managers

Heritage_small Peter Raaymakers

Hutz_small DarrenM

Editors

Sens_small Mark Parisi

Sens-suicidebooth_small Ryan Classic

Authors

Small DaveYoung

Karlssonpoint_small Adnan

Small Varada

Bobby__small bobbykelly

Bosch_small Amelia L