Is Daniel Alfredsson bound for the Hall of Fame?
Daniel Alfredsson is a hero in Ottawa. He is the Ottawa Senators' far-and-away leader in games played (951), goals (361), assists (580), points (941), powerplay goals (111), shorthanded goals (22), game-winning goals (59), game-tying goals (7), shots (2,811), playoff games played (101), playoff goals (43), playoff assists (37), playoff points (80), playoff powerplay goals (21), playoff game-winning goals (11), playoff overtime goals (2), playoff shots (316), just about anything you can think of. He is the face of the Senators franchise, he's active in the community, and he will--hopefully (although hopefully not too soon)--be the first player to suit up every career game as an Ottawa Senator and the first modern-day Senator to watch his number be retired.
For all his respect in the City of Ottawa, though, is Alfredsson respected well enough throughout the league and the hockey world to be Hockey Hall of Fame material once he does, in fact, retire? After the jump, I'll take a look at a few of the key factors in favour of Alfredsson when people look back on his career and consider his case for the Hall.
1. Leadership
With this his tenth season as the Ottawa Senators captain, Alfredsson is currently the longest-serving captain in the league. He was associate captain on the 2006 Swedish Olympic men's hockey team, and will likely be assistant captain on the 2010 team, too. I'm sure if you ask any player who's ever played with Alfredsson, each one will say they have respect for him as a leader in the game. The way he gives his all every game is inspiring, even when I'm sitting in the stands or watching on TV; I can't imagine what it would be like to play with him.
Update: Also, as correctly pointed out by a reader, Alfredsson also leads the team off the ice. He was among the first players to defer salary when the Senators were going through bankruptcy in order to allow for the acquisition of Peter Bondra during the team's playoff run. He's also significantly involved in the Royal Ottawa Health Care Group, to name just one of the charitable causes he promotes.
2. International play
The HHOF doesn't just recognize NHL play, though. It also recognizes international play, and Alfredsson is has had some of his greatest success playing for Sweden in international tournaments. First and foremost is, of course, his 2006 Olympic gold medal, with Alfredsson as the assistant captain. In 16GP over three Olympic tournaments, Alfredsson has 8G and 12A for 20P, and there is little doubt he'll add to those totals in the 2010 Olympics. He's also got two bronze (1999, 2001) and two silver medals (1995, 2004) in the World Championships. Pretty good numbers in international tournaments, for sure.
Alfredsson also had a taste of international success when he helped his hometown Frolunda Indians to their third-ever Swedish Elite League championship in 2005. He set franchise records for most goals (12) and most points (18) that playoff season, which still stand today.
3. Statistical success
Alfredsson currently sits 10th in career points among active players, and is 85 on the overall list. Without trying to jinx anything, and assuming he plays out the remainder of his contract, he could be expected to climb a good number of spots on that list (knock on wood). He's 14th among active players in playoff points, 124 overall,
4. Major trophies
Alfredsson was the first Senator to win a major NHL trophy when he was awarded the Calder Trophy for his rookie season. He's also been nominated for the Selke Trophy (2005-06, finished fourth in voting) and twice nominated for the Lady Byng Trophy (2003-04 and 2005-06, finished second and fourth in voting, respectively). There is little doubt he was Ottawa's strongest contender for the Conn Smythe Trophy of the 2007 playoffs, and some would argue he was close to winning it despite the fact that the Senators lost in the Stanley Cup Finals that season.
5. Random claims-to-fame
One reason why Alfredsson's already in the HHOF is because of the goal he scored against Toronto on Oct. 5, 2005, the decisive marker in the NHL's first-ever shootout. He was the first European born-and-trained captain to lead his team to the Stanley Cup Finals when he did so in 2007. He was honoured with a pillar in the Frolunda Indians' Scandinavium for his great play there.
*****
I'm not going to lie, I think Alfredsson's got everything on his resume to earn himself a spot in the Hall of Fame, and he's still going. Unfortunately, I'm not a member of the selection committee (yet) so my opinion doesn't mean much. Still, I'd be interested in your opinions: Is Daniel Alfredsson good enough for the Hall of Fame?
1 recs |
11 comments
|
Comments
Great stuff, Peter
I think it’s going to be hard to determine if he makes it or not. I personally figure he won’t make it in, because he was a bit of a late bloomer which hurts his stats (not to mention he missed a lot of games). It’d be great to see him in there, though.
Silver Seven: the Daniel Alfredsson of Ottawa Senators blogs.
by DarrenM on Nov 25, 2009 10:35 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Maybe?
It all depends on Alfie’s health moving forward and if he can stay healthy a reach the 500-goal plateau then it will be a resounding yes. Eventhough the Senators haven’t won the Stanley Cup during Alfredsson’s tenure as captain nobody can deny the success this franchise has had under his leadership. He is one of the most respected captains in the entire league, and has been for a while, so if he can hit some of those milestones then he may become a first-ballot electee.
It's never about the eventual destination, but rather the long journey and its challenging obstacles that are presented and what it takes to overcome them, that makes the taste of success all the more worthwhile!!!
by hawks61 on Nov 25, 2009 10:41 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
I would say 500 goals is far more than Alfie will reach. He’s only at 361 now, and he doesn’t have too many years left in him.
Silver Seven: the Daniel Alfredsson of Ottawa Senators blogs.
by DarrenM on Nov 25, 2009 11:04 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Well, if Alfredsson plays another 4-5 years then it becomes a possibility with him having to average 28 goals per season to accomplish this feat. Unlikely, but not totally impossible.
It's never about the eventual destination, but rather the long journey and its challenging obstacles that are presented and what it takes to overcome them, that makes the taste of success all the more worthwhile!!!
by hawks61 on Nov 25, 2009 12:03 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Maybe
Personally, I think a failure to win the Stanley Cup will keep him out.
by Mark Parisi on Nov 25, 2009 11:32 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
I really feel that in a team game this should not matter at all. Again, not that Alfie would necessarily make it in even with it (as his stats are borderline), but yeah, I realize Cup wins are a factor but they shouldn’t be.
Silver Seven: the Daniel Alfredsson of Ottawa Senators blogs.
by DarrenM on Nov 25, 2009 12:46 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Not yet...
Based on Alfredsson’s entire career, I can’t see it happening. Part of the reason I wanted to see Alfie/Sens win the Cup a few years ago was to help cement Alfie’s chances to get into the HHOF.
No cup doesn’t help. It’s not the be-all end-all, but its important (the Olympic gold helps though).
The other reason I don’t like his chances is the quality players that are becoming eligible. Not every HHOF eligible player will make it, unfortunately.
by Stayclassy.net on Nov 25, 2009 12:38 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Definitely possible
I think the one thing you need to factor in is how he ranks among other Swedes. As it stands right now I think he’s going to end up with career numbers second to Mats Sundin. Forsberg is a tougher gauge, but I think he’s in the same way Pavel Bure is in. Sundin and Forsberg were power forwards, whereas Alfie is a 2 way player who was only a minus player in his rookie season. As it stands if Alfie hits I think 85 points this season he’s going to be at 1000 career points with viably 3+ seasons left in the tank. And Alfie is a gamer, so barring injury I have no doubt he’ll play until at least 40. Even with diminishing returns I think he still puts up 60-70 points in the season and retires hitting 1200 points. I just looked at the all-time list and 1200 doesn’t put you in elite company, but when you factor in he’ll retire as the second highest scoring Swede of all time that bodes well for him. Also he’d probably get bonus points if he does play his whole career in Ottawa. 1200 points from a guy who was a 6th round pick is pretty good too. I’d say putting in a Hall of Famer from one of the 1990’s expansion teams probably would have some appeal to the hall voters too.
by modsuperstar on Nov 27, 2009 10:43 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Alfredsson is probably not going to the Hall of Fame. He is 37 years old and has 900 something career points. It doesn’t look likely that he will get sufficiently far up the all time scoring list to get there. Aside from a 1996 Calder Trophy, he has no major awards. He has never been a serious MVP candidate. you are incoprrect listing his award nominations. The top three players in voting get nominations – so his fourth place finishes do not get him nominations. All he has for award nominations is a Lady Byng – which isn’t much.
He has been one of the top scorers of the past decade, but far enough down the list that alone would not get him into the hall.
Alfredsson is unlikely to make it. He has to stay at the top of his game for a few more years for it to happen and his age is getting up there. Perhaps if he didn’t have as many partial seasons due to injury in the 1990s or if he put up a 100 point year in 2004/05 (instead of the lockout) we might be thinking otherwise, but right now I would be against it.
by PuckStopsHere on Nov 28, 2009 11:46 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
I think he’s borderline. No Cup and only a Calder trophy…he’s really loved in Ottawa but he might not crack 1,000 points or 500 goals, both of which are earmarks for the Hall of Fame.
He was close to winning the Conn Smythe in 2007 though and he has a ton of international accolades.
Not sure really. Guys like Ciccarelli and Gilmour aren’t in (the latter has a Cup, Selkes, 100 point seasons) and Pat Quinn is a HHOF selection member :p
by BesterThanYesterday on Dec 8, 2009 11:53 PM EST reply actions 0 recs

by 
















